Why Phil Collins Can't Stand Simon Cowell - Grunge

Simon Cowell made a name within the British music industry as a talent scout and executive, but his fame among general audiences came through talent shows such as “Pop Idol” and “American Idol.” Some in the music business who’ve gone after Cowell take more of an issue with the concept of such shows than with any one judge; Elton John dismissed talent shows as unhelpful and refused to be a guest judge on “American Idol.” Phil Collins hasn’t gone that far. In a 2005 interview with TV Guide, he likened the show and similar programs to older variety shows, which he was a fan of.

In Collins’ case, Cowell and his attitude was the black mark on “American Idol.” “I’ve got no time for Simon Cowell,” he said. “[He] is just cruel and that’s all there is to it.” Collins specifically cited a moment on the show when Cowell insulted a woman whose day job was singing on boats. “I’d never go on a boat you were singing on because it would sink,” he told her. Collins said that Cowell acted above those he was ostensibly meant to help, which poisoned the whole experience of the show.

When asked by TV Guide if he’d ever go on “American Idol” as a guest judge, Collins demurred. He considered the possibility of offering real encouragement to contestants, but added, “That show is such a format now, it would probably just be banging my head against the wall.”

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading