
U.S. District Judge J. Michael Seabright shut down the top federal prosecutor in the seven Southern and Central California counties at the end of October, but the Justice Department is begging for more time before he’s shoved out. Bloomberg Law reported Tuesday that the judge refused.
The White House appointed several U.S. attorneys who were not approved by the U.S. Senate. There’s a deadline that an interim U.S. attorney must be confirmed or they’re out in 120 days. When the date expires, a district court can appoint someone else.
Bill Essayli wasn’t confirmed by the U.S. Senate, so he’s stayed in the office under a new title: First Assistant U.S. Attorney. Dean Steward, an defense attorney, challenged Essayli’s position and filed a motion for reconsideration of a motion to dismiss charges against his client Tu Anh Tran. He then said that the judge should disqualify Essayli after Judge Seabright earlier ruled Essayli could stay in his job as the so-called “first assistant U.S. attorney.”
Seabright said in his ruling that the government “concedes that it will suffer no injury from the immediate, practical effect” of being involved in two cases involving Jaime Hector Ramirez and Tu Anh Tran. Ramirez is on trial for unlawful possession of a firearm and Anh Tran stands accused of possession of property stolen from interstate or foreign shipment. Both cases are to be tried next week, local news reported, but now there’s a concern that if Essayli remains in the job the cases could be in jeopardy.
“Instead, it raises broad separation of powers concerns, identifying the potential injury as the alleged fact `that a court has displaced the executive’s choice and reassigned supervision of criminal prosecutors on a theory that … no other court … has yet to apply,’” Seabright wrote.
Courts have also rejected arrangements used to install or retain Trump administration prosecutors in New Jersey and Virginia, although the appointment histories and legal issues were somewhat different.
Seabright also said that “for the first time” prosecutors acknowledged the issue could affect “5,000 cases in the largest district in the country.” Seabright rejected that argument, writing that “this bald assertion, absent any support or explanation, does not establish probable irreparable injury.”
Essayli has appealed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. However, the appeals court already disqualified Nevada prosecutor Sigal Chattah in a similar case. Seabright had initially been fine with Essayli’s running the office, but has reconsidered after the Ninth Circuit decision on Chattah.

