
We can assume Bullock and deputy governor Andrew Hauser were in the vanguard of the six. In recent times they have been hawks in the fight against inflation, judging that to lose that fight would be catastrophic, even if the battle is bringing a lot of pain.
We do know hiking rates was a contested call – taken on a six to three vote – given the economic uncertainty and the danger of depressing activity too far.
Given higher interest rates and the challenges coming at us from around the world, it’s unsurprising to see unemployment tick up, but that doesn’t make it any less of a concern to Australians.
Critics of the bank’s decision believe it is ignoring the lags involved in monetary policy – that the earlier hikes should have been given more time to have their effect.
Only recently some were speculating about another rate rise in February.
Read this between the lines of Chalmers’ reaction to the job numbers:
Whoever they are, they would be vindicated if the board found in coming days it had slammed on the brakes too hard and had to reduce rates in the relatively short term. From the bank’s point of view, that would be a break-glass moment.
These figures show the very real and serious pressure Australians are under right now.
They also placed somewhat less weight than the other members on the upside risks to inflation and somewhat more weight on the downside risks to economic growth.
Remember the bank has a dual mandate – to contain inflation and to maintain employment – and at times like this it can be a fine-judgment juggle.
We knew on the day the broad concerns of the minority who opposed the rate rise. The board’s minutes, released this week, spell out the detail of the dissent. They say:
These members expressed their concern that the economy might be near the point of entering a materially sharper downturn and pointed to the costs in terms of unemployment.
There is a board meeting in December, but that would surely be too early for second thoughts. It is expected to hold rates.
Basically, what will happen with rates next and when it will happen seem in the “known unknowns” category.
Meanwhile, we can only hope both Chalmers and Bullock are right when they dismiss the danger of recession. Getting that wrong would trash the reputations of both but, more important, would devastate the lives of many Australians and destroy many businesses.
We can assume the government, if we were back in the days when a treasurer could, in effect, dictate to the bank, would have said no to a November rate rise.
Of course, as Bullock says, it will “feel like a recession” for many, even if the economy stays in positive territory.
Treasurer Jim Chalmers is under enormous pressure over the government’s economic management, but this week’s higher-than- expected unemployment rate underlines that the reputation of Reserve Bank Governor Michele Bullock is increasingly on the line.
A minority of members determined instead that the case to leave the cash rate target unchanged at this meeting was the stronger one. These members judged that, having tightened policy in September to mitigate the upside risks to inflation, it was prudent to leave more time to assess how the 100 basis points of tightening already delivered would affect the economy.
The following meeting is in February. As one economic analyst observed: “February now feels an age away”.
We can’t be sure whether the 4.9% October unemployment figure, up from 4.7% in September, gave Bullock any pause for thought about whether the bank made the right decision in raising interest rates at this month’s meeting.
We would presume one of the three dissenters was treasury secretary Jenny Wilkinson. We don’t know the other two.

